The Unwritten Rules of History

Category: Editorials (Page 1 of 3)

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Jewish Tradition on Rosh Hashanah

image of Ruth Bader Ginsburg

Simmie Knox, under commission of the United States Supreme Court / Public domain

I was originally planning to write a blog post sharing the new interview that I did with Samantha Cutrara, on my research on Jewish women and cultural traditions, especially around food (more on this below). But I’ve also been troubled by the news coverage and responses to death of Ruth Bader Ginsburg. So I ended up writing a Twitter thread, about it, and I decided to share what I wrote over here. Also because, for reasons(?), it got all out of order on Twitter.

Continue reading

Stronger Together: The Potential Collaborative Agency of Historians and Archivists

by Andrea Eidinger and Krista McCracken

(Cross posted on Active History)

Over the past few years, the historical community in Canada has been rocked by a few scandals. No, we are not talking about the endless discussions around monuments. Rather, we are referring to the numerous public disputes between historians and archivists relating either to the discovery of or access to archival material. For example, you’ve liked seen various historians announcing that they had “discovered” a long-lost historical document by looking in a seemingly forgotten corner of the archive. To which archivists often reply, we knew it was there the whole time. Sometimes we also see these conflicts erupt into larger disputes, as has been the case with respect to the recent announcement that the BC Archives would be closed until 2021 to ensure that proper procedures were in place to protect staff and visitors from COVID-19.

 

Continue reading

2019 Holiday Gift Guide for Historians and History Professionals

Header image of three toy Christmas trees against a white backdrop

Do you know a Canadian historian? (::nods::) Are they impossible to shop for because they already own all the books? (::nods vigorously::) Then have we got just the thing for you!

As promised, we’re back with our Fourth Annual Holiday Gift Guide for Historians and History Professionals! This is becoming a veritable Canadian history holiday tradition. I’ll keep the preamble short, but as usual, standard caveats apply:

  • Warning to loved ones of historians and history professionals: It is so lovely that you remembered that we love history and that most of us love reading. However, we strongly recommend against the purchase of history books for holiday gifts, unless they are specifically requested. If you are dead-set on buying a history book for your loved-one, at least make sure that it is: from an academic press (it will say the word University in the title of the publisher) and it is by a person with a Ph.D. in history (Google is your friend – just put their name and the word history to find out). You may also want to make sure that your loved-one doesn’t already own the book in question, or have easy access to it from their institutional library. We have provided a couple of suggestions for non-history books that might be a better fit.
  • While I am Canadian, and many of the recommendations I’ve included down below are specific to Canadian history, this list should be helpful to history professionals no matter their country of origin or residence.
  • Finally, while there are plenty of options here for history enthusiasts, this guide is specifically intended for individuals who are shopping for historians and historical professionals.

I also know that our gift guide is out rather late this year, mostly because I wasn’t planning to do one. And I’m sure that all of my fellow historians and history professionals have already completed their holiday shopping, so this guide is entirely unnecessary, right? 😉

Don’t forget to check out our guides from 2016, 2017, and 2018. While not all of the links work anymore, there are still plenty of fantastic ideas to be found. The leather book weight from 2018 is still a highlight. And don’t forget that the 2017 guide contains additional information if you will be purchasing or making gifts for your Jewish friends.

Once again, I have cheekily divided this list according to academic rank, mostly because I still think it’s funny. Enjoy!

 

Continue reading

Is This Thing Still On?

 

Mic against a colourful background

Tap tap tap

Before you get excited, I’m not actually back! I’m just popping in with some news!

So, first of all, if you’ve been missing my writing, I have good news for you. I’ve recently started writing the University Affairs’s Careers Café column! You can check out my first two pieces, on opportunities and online job announcements.  Here’s a preview of the latter:

Digital technology, including social media, has dramatically transformed the academic landscape over the last 10 years. Some of these changes have been positive, and some negative. Some platforms like Twitter have facilitated the creation of online communities for academics, creating spaces where we can provide support for each other, engage in conversation, and share our work. But at the same time, new publication venues, like blogs, have put even more pressure on graduate students and early career academics to produce material. Other changes are less easily categorized, but raise important questions that we, as a field, need to address. In this case, I’m speaking about the increasingly common practice of online job announcements. To be clear, I’m not referring to job ads, but rather, the announcements from the individuals who get the jobs and/or promotions.

Secondly, Stephanie and I have been chatting about what to do with Unwritten Histories. We’ve basically come to the conclusion that we’d like to keep everything up, and write occasional posts when the mood strikes us. I don’t think we’ll reactivate the Patreon account right now, though maybe we can consider switching to a per-post model. I’d love to hear your thoughts on the subject.

And on that note, keep your eye out for a brand new blog post on Tuesday. I wasn’t planning to do a gift guide for this year, but I couldn’t resist it. See you then!

Cultivating a Conscientious Citation Practice

neon sign in different colours, spelling need, dream, human, desire, hope.

 

I absolutely love citations. There is something beautiful about a perfectly formatted bibliography that just makes my heart sing. But aside from their aesthetic value, citations have tremendous transformative potential when it comes to academia, education, and the sharing of knowledge. So, in today’s blog post, I want to talk about why this is the case, and how you can maximize the potential of citations in your classroom.

This blog post was inspired by a recent Facebook post by the talented and lovely Joanna L. Pearce, which I will include below. While I was writing this blog post, I also happened to mention my plan to Krista McCracken, who was already planning to do a podcast episode on the same subject (in case you needed more evidence that our minds are psychically synced). So while I will be talking about citations in terms of education today, Krista will be speaking about citations and research; definitely make sure you check out that podcast episode.

  Continue reading

Creating Kind, Brave, and Curious Spaces in Academia

selective focus photography of person holding lighted brown string light

Special thanks to Krista McCracken, Jessica Knapp, Maddie Knickerbocker, and Lee Blanding for helping me develop the ideas in this blog post.

 

This week marks the third anniversary of the creation of Unwritten Histories! In past years, we’ve celebrated in a couple of different ways. For our first anniversary, we took at a look at the first year of Unwritten Histories by the numbers. For our second anniversary, we profiled some amazing women-identified graduate students and recent graduates working across the country. I have to admit, I’ve been struggling to figure out what to do this year. But in light of recent events at the NCPH and in the Ethnicity, Race, and Migration program at Yale, and after having some long talks with my amazing friends, I’ve decided to take this opportunity to imagine what my ideal academic world would look like. Since this is a blog post, and you know that I am interested in practical solutions, I’ve decided to focus on three qualities that I think my ideal academic world would embrace: kindness, bravery, and curiosity. Below I talk about each one of these in turn, and offer some suggestions about how we can bring these three qualities in our life today. While change doesn’t happen overnight, small interventions can make a big difference, and

 

Continue reading

Check out my latest blog post on Active History!

Here is a preview:

On April 3rd, I was on my way to class, when I received a phone call from my husband. It was the last day of the winter semester, and my students had organized a potluck to celebrate. My husband has battled Crohn’s Disease for the better part of ten years, and had decided to stay home that day because his symptoms were severe. Over the course of those ten years, we’ve been through several flares (as they are called), and knew what to do. So my husband calling me right before class time was quite out of character. And for good reason: he called to tell me that he needed to go to the hospital. After a brief discussion (he wanted me to go to class, I told him he was being ridiculous), I popped into class to explain what was going on, and then ran to catch the bus. That was one of the longest commutes my entire life, both literally and figuratively. I arrived at the hospital to find my husband curled up on the benches in the Emergency Room. While I didn’t know it at the time, we had just entered a two-month-long hell-scape that involved multiple emergency room visits, two major surgeries, and a lot of waiting. I’m happy to report that my husband is now doing fine, but the entire ordeal has highlighted the invisible costs of precarious academia, particularly those costs that arise from academic relocation.

 

Check out the rest here: http://activehistory.ca/2019/02/untethered-precarity-place-and-people/

A Love Letter To My Teaching Self

Image of a vintage typewriter, surrounded by flowers, paper, coffee cup, a green leather notebook, a camera, classes, and lettering type..

Special thanks to Jessica Knapp, Krista McCracken, and Maddie Knickerbocker for their encouragement and comments on a draft of this piece.

 

Dear Teaching Self

Hey it’s me. I know we don’t talk often. And I know that you’re not teaching right now. But since it’s almost Valentine’s Day, I just wanted to write you this little note anyways to let you know that I get it. Teaching is super hard. It can totally be awesome, and I know how much you love telling stories and talking about history. But it’s also a ton of work. Coming up with a syllabus is really hard, and it’s challenging to pick just the right readings. Preparing lectures and PowerPoint presentations always seems to take longer than it should. Most of your students are awesome, but there are always a couple who seem to want to make your job harder (omg, remember the student who tried to correct you with Wikipedia? In front of the entire class?). And while you’re in class, you feel great, but as soon as it’s over, you feel like a train wreck, simultaneously “on” and exhausted?  And you often find yourself wondering what it is you’re doing in the first place, and whether anything is even getting through?

 

Continue reading

Teaching in Comfort and Style in Post-Secondary Education

Image of a wooden vintage shoe stretcher on a weathered dresser.

Special thanks to all of the people who took the time to answer my questions, including David Dolff, Samantha Cutrara, Tina Adcock, Sarah Van Vugt, Danielle Lorenz, Catherine Ulmer, Michelle-Kelly Hogan, Tarisa Dawn Little, Gillian Leitch, Krista McCracken, Claire Campbell, Maddie Knickerbocker, Wendy McElroy, Carol Lynn, Crystal Fraser, Ling Ling Ang, Anne Dance, Krystl Raven, Danielle Robinson, Vanessa McLeod, Shannon Stettner, Anne Marie Lane Jonah, Tarah Brookfield, Erin Millions, Aisha Wynter, Michelle Desveaux, Anne Janhunen, Mary Chaktsiris, Stephanie Pettigrew, Beth A. Robertson, Shirley Tillotson, Janis Thiessen, Linda Steer, Tracey Kinney, Blair Stein, Christine Corcos, Kesia Kvill, Jenny Leigh Smith, Katy Kole de Peralta, Elise Chenier, Caroline Durand, Laura Ishiguro, and Jennifer Hoyt. Extra special thanks to Sarah Van Vugt, Krystl Raven, Erin Millions, Kesia Kvill, Laura Ishiguro, Caroline Durand, and Krista McCracken for feedback on an earlier draft of this paper!

I recently put out a call on my Facebook page asking for recommendations for comfortable black dress shoes for someone who hates heels. Long story short, my old reliable black flats were dead, and the cobbler said they were too decrepit to even repair. Since I was going to be in Ottawa soon (more on this later), however, I needed to find something. I received a ton of awesome recommendations from friends of mine. They were so good in fact that I thought they deserved their own blog post.

When many of us first start teaching, clothing can be a fraught issue. We struggle to look professional while also still being comfortable. Lecturing involves a great deal more physical activity than many of us realize – standing on your feet for one to three hours takes its toll. Most classes also tend to be taught in older buildings, which don’t necessarily have air conditioning or heating, or even windows that open. So, in today’s blog post, I’m going to give you some great recommendations for teaching in comfort and style, from me and an awesome group of other educators. This isn’t necessarily a very original idea,  and there have even been some great blogs on the subject (RIP Academichic). However, most of these are American, and don’t really help us Canadians. Not only do we have different stores here, but Canadian classrooms have their own norms regarding dress. One important note: while most blog posts of this nature target women specifically (something I’ll deal with further on), I wanted to make sure that this specific post was inclusive of any and all genders. That is why I have divided it into clothing categories, rather than breaking things down by gender. And most importantly, while these are just some recommendations, I think it’s important to emphasize that you should wear what makes YOU feel comfortable and stylish. Enjoy!

As usual, one quick caveat: There continue to be significant variations by field and by country in what is considered appropriate dress. In my experience, Canada tends to be much more casual than the United States, particularly in the Humanities and Social Sciences. I can’t remember ever seeing a professor wearing a suit to class. For the most part, people tend to go with variations on business casual. Those in Fine Arts tend to have more leeway in terms of creativity, while those in Law tend to dress more conservatively in suits or dresses. However, this will of course vary from institution to institution, and depend to a large extent on campus culture.

Finally, as one commentator noted, in the vast majority of cases, it is important to remember that it is never ok to talk about another person’s body, appearance, or clothing choices, no matter the circumstances. Even well-intentioned and seemingly-innocent remarks can be problematic, misread, and can make folks feel uncomfortable. It is equally important not to police other people’s clothing choices according to what you feel is acceptable. We could all use a little more kindness in our world, and it’s always ok to compliment someone on a nice outfit. But it is also our responsibility to do the work necessary to make everyone feel included and safe. Or, in the immortal words of Etsy, be kind, be brave, and be strong.

 

Continue reading

Historians in Public

Note from Andrea: we have a very special blog post today, that is also being shared on Active History and Histories Engagée. This post was originally published in the “Word from the President” column in Intersections 1.3. Special thanks to Adele Perry, the CHA, and Jim Clifford for making this happen.

By Adele Perry

The CHA|SHC is one of the organizations involved with The|La Collaborative, a Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council [SSHRC] of Canada-funded network dedicated to fostering Social Sciences and Humanities knowledge and skills in society at large.[1]  In part, this involves discussing and promoting a range of different ways of being a social science or humanities scholar outside of the formal academy: in elementary and secondary classrooms, in media both new and old, and wherever we might find opportunity and cause to demonstrate the capacity of scholarly practice.

What historians can contribute to this is a long and I think notable history of practising our scholarship in public. In 2010, Joy Parr explained that historical practice “attentive to contemporary concerns, engaged in policy and with an engaged citizenry has existed as long as historical scholarship has existed in Canada.”[2]  The causes, communities, and issues that historians engage with have changed, as have the tools and technologies that historians use to engage and communicate.  But the basic fact of historians’ willingness to connect their research to the present and to speak to communities beyond the archive and classroom is longstanding.

In the last decade, Canada’s historical community have seen a number of new initiatives that mobilize historical knowledge and expertise to contribute to wider discussions.  These are notable and worth discussing in a forum like Intersections unto themselves.  That these initiatives are significantly organized and maintained by junior scholars, many of whom who have done so without the resources of tenure-track or tenured appointments, should give us all additional pause.  As a profession, our capacity to engage robustly with wider conversations and publics is not threatened by scholarly disinterest as much as it is by a precarious condition that a generation of historians are compelled to navigate.

Continue reading

« Older posts

© 2024 Unwritten Histories

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑